Iron Butterfly Options Strategy: How the Pin Pays and When It Does Not

An iron butterfly is a short straddle with insurance: you sell the at-the-money call and put for the most premium available, then buy cheap wings so the worst case is…

Stack of smooth stones balanced on one another against a plain white background

An iron butterfly is a short straddle with insurance: you sell the at-the-money call and put for the most premium available, then buy cheap wings so the worst case is known in advance. It pays the most when the stock finishes exactly where it started, and the price of that high credit is a narrow profit zone that the stock has to respect for weeks.

Key Takeaways

  • An iron butterfly has four legs in one expiration: sell an at-the-money call and put at the same strike (the body), then buy an out-of-the-money call above and an out-of-the-money put below (the wings).
  • Maximum profit is the net credit, earned only if the stock closes at the body strike. Maximum loss is the wing width minus the credit.
  • Compared with an iron condor, the butterfly collects roughly twice the credit in the example below but has a profit zone about a third narrower.
  • Because the short strikes sit at the money, gamma is highest here. Most of the profit comes early; the last stretch is where the risk lives.
  • All prices and strikes below are hypothetical and illustrative. They are not trade recommendations.

How an Iron Butterfly Is Built

Every leg shares one expiration, usually 21 to 45 days out. Using an illustrative stock at $100:

Two shorts at one strike are the body, and the wings are the protection. If you removed the wings you would have a short straddle, which has the same peak profit and no cap on the loss. The wings cost a little premium and take the unlimited-risk tail off the table.

The Math on a Hypothetical Trade

Assume a stock at $100 with 30 days to expiration and these invented prices: the $100 call and the $100 put each sell for $3.00, the $110 call costs $0.55, and the $90 put costs $0.50.

Hypothetical iron butterfly
Credit from the short options $3.00 + $3.00 = $6.00
Cost of the wings $0.55 + $0.50 = $1.05
Net credit $4.95 ($495 per spread)
Maximum profit $495, if the stock is exactly $100 at expiration
Maximum loss $10.00 wing width minus $4.95 = $5.05 ($505 per spread)
Upper break-even $100 + $4.95 = $104.95
Lower break-even $100 – $4.95 = $95.05
Maximum loss occurs if the stock at expiration is At or above $110, or at or below $90

Two things stand out. First, the break-evens sit only about 5% either side of the starting price, so the stock has to stay in a $9.90-wide window to make any money at expiration. Second, the risk and reward are nearly one to one: risking $505 to make at most $495. That is unusual for a premium-selling trade, and it is the direct result of selling at-the-money options.

Iron Butterfly vs. Iron Condor

The iron condor is the same idea with the short strikes pushed out of the money. Here is a hypothetical condor on the same stock with the same $10 wing width: sell the $105 call at $1.40 and buy the $115 call at $0.20, then sell the $95 put at $1.30 and buy the $85 put at $0.25.

Iron butterfly Iron condor
Short strikes $100 call and $100 put $105 call and $95 put
Net credit $4.95 $2.25
Maximum loss $5.05 $7.75
Break-even range $95.05 to $104.95 $92.75 to $107.25
Width of profit zone $9.90 $14.50
Peak profit requires Stock exactly at $100 Stock anywhere from $95 to $105

The butterfly pays more than twice the credit and risks less, but its zone is about a third narrower and its maximum profit is a single price. The condor gives you a band to be right inside. Neither is better in the abstract: you are choosing between a higher payout for a more precise forecast and a smaller payout for a looser one.

When an Iron Butterfly Makes Sense

The structure is a bet that the stock does less than the options imply, so the setup matters more than the mechanics.

Managing and Closing the Trade

Because the profit zone is narrow, the exit plan is part of the strategy rather than an afterthought.

Take profits early. Collecting the full $495 requires the stock to be at exactly $100 at expiration, which almost never happens. A common approach is to close at a fraction of maximum profit. In the hypothetical, 25% is about $124 and 50% is about $248. The last portion of profit is the hardest to capture and exposes you to the largest swings in position value, for the least remaining reward. The same logic is laid out for condors in the 21 DTE and 50% profit exit guide.

Define the loss before you enter. The maximum loss is built in, but many traders exit well before reaching it, for example when the stock reaches a break-even or when the position has lost a set multiple of the credit. Pick the rule in advance.

Respect gamma. With short options at the money, small stock moves change the position’s value quickly, and the effect grows every day closer to expiration. A $2 move in the stock can change the spread’s value much more in the last week than in the first.

Know the expiration risks. If the stock sits near the body at expiration, one short leg is likely in the money and can be assigned. A short option that is in the money near expiration can also be assigned early. Most traders close the whole spread before expiration rather than let it settle. If your trade goes wrong early rather than late, the adjustment ideas in the iron condor adjustment guide apply in part, though a butterfly gives you less room to maneuver.

What It Costs to Trade

Four legs means four per-contract fees to open and, at many brokers, four to close. The figures below use each broker’s published options commission from our verified broker data and exclude exchange and regulatory fees, which vary by product and are small but not zero.

Broker Published options commission Open one iron butterfly (4 contracts) Last verified
tastytrade $1.00 to open, $0 to close, capped at $10 per leg $4.00 to open, $0 to close 2026-10-03
Interactive Brokers (IBKR Pro) Premium-tiered; $0.65 per contract at $0.10 or more premium, lower on very cheap options Up to $2.60 to open and up to $2.60 to close 2026-10-03

On a trade that nets under $500, a $4 open fee is under 1% of the maximum profit, so commissions matter less here than they do on a $20 credit spread. They matter most if you open and close many butterflies a month. Rates change, so check each broker’s current terms before relying on the numbers.

Who Should Skip It

Bottom Line

An iron butterfly trades a narrow profit zone for the highest credit a defined-risk premium seller can collect. Use it when implied volatility is elevated, the big event is behind the stock, and you have a reason to expect it to stay near a level. Take profits early rather than waiting for a perfect pin, and close the spread before the last week.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the difference between an iron butterfly and an iron condor?
A: An iron butterfly sells the call and put at the same at-the-money strike, which brings in more credit but creates a narrow profit zone. An iron condor sells out-of-the-money options at two different strikes, which brings in less credit and gives the stock a wider range to finish in.

Q: What is the maximum loss on an iron butterfly?
A: The width of the wings minus the net credit you received, per share, times 100 per contract. In the hypothetical above, that is $10.00 minus $4.95, or $505 per spread, plus fees.

Q: Where are the break-evens?
A: The body strike plus the net credit, and the body strike minus the net credit. With a $100 body and $4.95 credit, they are $104.95 and $95.05.

Q: When should I close an iron butterfly?
A: Set the rule before you enter. Many traders close at 25% to 50% of maximum profit, or when a break-even is reached, and avoid holding into the final week, when price swings change the position’s value fastest.

Q: Is an iron butterfly the same as a short straddle?
A: It has the same body but adds two purchased wings. That caps the loss at a known amount, whereas a short straddle has no upper limit on its risk.


Keep learning: See the opposite side of this trade in long straddles and strangles, then browse the Strategy Guides hub for more defined-risk setups.